darkvortex
Smash Champion
- Joined
- Jul 1, 2023
- Messages
- 2,407
Thoughts on our lineup. Skipping Miku as she is my own submission -
Rayman - If we go for a westren scrimblo platformer then I think this is the best bet. He doesn't have the most active life right now but he's a huge request and fits the vibe pretty easily. Dispite being neglected by his publisher, I think this a Banjo case where he makes the most sense over stuff like ac due to fan demand. Plus his stage will eh great. legends and origins are like top ten best 2d platformers imo
Hyabusa - Pretty big character. another huge fan request and a big publisher who have yet to get a rep. Ninjas are cool. Personally I think there are more interesting options but he could have a great moveset
Dante - Now. As someone who was a big Dante person during Ultimate, I do wonder if we have too much falcon right now. It's got Ryu, Ken, Mega Man, Roll, Phoenix, Jill, Leon. Six characters. I just wonder if we should spend this spot on another. We also have the character action thing highly covered. However I do think he's a great pull from a fandom pleasing perspective. He could also have a great moveset.
Saber - Saber had a couple close calls during our previous DLC rounds. she's from a dried that's huge in Japan, but somewhat nechie overseas. I don't think this a bad thing persay. she kind of me of Sakura in that she's a fairly neiche character who users in the thread are really passionate about. I think we could do something cool with her. another swordy, but from my limited knowledge it seems like she's got a lot to pull from.
Sub\Scorp - Man. We've got a lot of fighting games. Ryu, Ken, Terry, Rock, Kazuya, Jin, Nightmare, Sol. Eight. That's a lot. MK is super iconic though, and MK vs SF is something fans have wanted to see since these franchises began. It is pretty unknown in Japan, but I don't think that matters too much. I also don't think the violence is too and an issue, we have Doomslayer and Bayonetta and Scorpion and Sub-Zero have thrown it done with the Justice League, it can be done. I do wanna spread the genre love about more though.
Bomberman - Pretty iconic character. One of the big Nintendo but not Nintendo mascot types left. I personally think he's fine in the role he's in, and I say this as someone who likes his games a fair bit. I've yet to see a moveset that really wows me. I like the little guy though.
Hunter - MH is a deeply iconic series, but as I said with Dante we have a lot of Capcom. Not only that but MH is pretty well prepped with a boss and a stage, there's more locations we could pull from of course, there's endless moveset potential too. I personally just think they're fine with what they have.
Master Chief - Now if we want a Sora level pick this is the one. We don't really have a full homegrown Microsoft rep, and with Ratchet in I think that's something that would be really cool, to get a true Ninty vs PS vs XBOX showdown. Halo is a super iconic game and I really don't think his similarities to Doomslayer matter. My issue with Cheif has always been. How I think he'd play. I think Cheif in modern Namco era smash would be a really annoying zoner, but we get to dictate the movesets here so I guess it's not a big deal. I'm no Halo fan but I understand how huge this would be.
Rabbid - I get the reasoning behind this, I do. But I'd just rather have Rayman, I'm sorry. I do think they could have a crazy wacky fun moveset, and I actually have a lot of love for the Rabbids games, but I just think it should be Rayman.
Jaina - Warcraft is a massive franchise. MMO's are a huge part of gaming that Smash Hasan really touched on at all. And aside from maybe FF14, WOW is a the biggest one. However, maybe this is the super casual in me but I really feel like the Warcraft rep should be an Orc? when someone thinks of World of Warcraft, they think of Orcs. They mad e above all about the Orcs. I know Jaina is a popular and important character, but I just think it's a wired direction to take this in
Chell - Valve is a huge publisher, and getting a rep from them could be cool. We do already have a Portal stage though. I do think the Portal gun could have been a cool item but I don't think of Chell herself as much of af ighter really. Portals could be fun gimmick but like, what would she do other than that? It's not impossible to make her work but I think there are other ways to represent the franchise.
D.Va - You know. I actually kinda like this! OW is a big franchise, despite the lackluster reception to the sequel. It's a game that's known for its popular characters, so adding one does make sense. I know everyone is gonna go for Tracer first, and I do think she could be cool, but I do think this is an ARMS case where it doesn't need to be the cover stat. D.Va is like one of the most recognisable characters and I just think the idea of a mech user is fun, I remember that old fake leak from Ultimate about a female mech user. We do have Eggman and I guess DJ Octavio but this would be different. OW has dropped in popularity though so I wonder if the timing is right
Carmen - I'm all for wacky outside the box picks but I'm not sure I feel this one. I'm aware she started out as a game character, and while I know this is very rich coming from the person who submitted Miku, but I just think of her more as a cartoon character than anything. There's probably a fun moveset you could do but this just isn't one I have any attachment to. I mean no disrespect, every submission is vaild.
Rayman - If we go for a westren scrimblo platformer then I think this is the best bet. He doesn't have the most active life right now but he's a huge request and fits the vibe pretty easily. Dispite being neglected by his publisher, I think this a Banjo case where he makes the most sense over stuff like ac due to fan demand. Plus his stage will eh great. legends and origins are like top ten best 2d platformers imo
Hyabusa - Pretty big character. another huge fan request and a big publisher who have yet to get a rep. Ninjas are cool. Personally I think there are more interesting options but he could have a great moveset
Dante - Now. As someone who was a big Dante person during Ultimate, I do wonder if we have too much falcon right now. It's got Ryu, Ken, Mega Man, Roll, Phoenix, Jill, Leon. Six characters. I just wonder if we should spend this spot on another. We also have the character action thing highly covered. However I do think he's a great pull from a fandom pleasing perspective. He could also have a great moveset.
Saber - Saber had a couple close calls during our previous DLC rounds. she's from a dried that's huge in Japan, but somewhat nechie overseas. I don't think this a bad thing persay. she kind of me of Sakura in that she's a fairly neiche character who users in the thread are really passionate about. I think we could do something cool with her. another swordy, but from my limited knowledge it seems like she's got a lot to pull from.
Sub\Scorp - Man. We've got a lot of fighting games. Ryu, Ken, Terry, Rock, Kazuya, Jin, Nightmare, Sol. Eight. That's a lot. MK is super iconic though, and MK vs SF is something fans have wanted to see since these franchises began. It is pretty unknown in Japan, but I don't think that matters too much. I also don't think the violence is too and an issue, we have Doomslayer and Bayonetta and Scorpion and Sub-Zero have thrown it done with the Justice League, it can be done. I do wanna spread the genre love about more though.
Bomberman - Pretty iconic character. One of the big Nintendo but not Nintendo mascot types left. I personally think he's fine in the role he's in, and I say this as someone who likes his games a fair bit. I've yet to see a moveset that really wows me. I like the little guy though.
Hunter - MH is a deeply iconic series, but as I said with Dante we have a lot of Capcom. Not only that but MH is pretty well prepped with a boss and a stage, there's more locations we could pull from of course, there's endless moveset potential too. I personally just think they're fine with what they have.
Master Chief - Now if we want a Sora level pick this is the one. We don't really have a full homegrown Microsoft rep, and with Ratchet in I think that's something that would be really cool, to get a true Ninty vs PS vs XBOX showdown. Halo is a super iconic game and I really don't think his similarities to Doomslayer matter. My issue with Cheif has always been. How I think he'd play. I think Cheif in modern Namco era smash would be a really annoying zoner, but we get to dictate the movesets here so I guess it's not a big deal. I'm no Halo fan but I understand how huge this would be.
Rabbid - I get the reasoning behind this, I do. But I'd just rather have Rayman, I'm sorry. I do think they could have a crazy wacky fun moveset, and I actually have a lot of love for the Rabbids games, but I just think it should be Rayman.
Jaina - Warcraft is a massive franchise. MMO's are a huge part of gaming that Smash Hasan really touched on at all. And aside from maybe FF14, WOW is a the biggest one. However, maybe this is the super casual in me but I really feel like the Warcraft rep should be an Orc? when someone thinks of World of Warcraft, they think of Orcs. They mad e above all about the Orcs. I know Jaina is a popular and important character, but I just think it's a wired direction to take this in
Chell - Valve is a huge publisher, and getting a rep from them could be cool. We do already have a Portal stage though. I do think the Portal gun could have been a cool item but I don't think of Chell herself as much of af ighter really. Portals could be fun gimmick but like, what would she do other than that? It's not impossible to make her work but I think there are other ways to represent the franchise.
D.Va - You know. I actually kinda like this! OW is a big franchise, despite the lackluster reception to the sequel. It's a game that's known for its popular characters, so adding one does make sense. I know everyone is gonna go for Tracer first, and I do think she could be cool, but I do think this is an ARMS case where it doesn't need to be the cover stat. D.Va is like one of the most recognisable characters and I just think the idea of a mech user is fun, I remember that old fake leak from Ultimate about a female mech user. We do have Eggman and I guess DJ Octavio but this would be different. OW has dropped in popularity though so I wonder if the timing is right
Carmen - I'm all for wacky outside the box picks but I'm not sure I feel this one. I'm aware she started out as a game character, and while I know this is very rich coming from the person who submitted Miku, but I just think of her more as a cartoon character than anything. There's probably a fun moveset you could do but this just isn't one I have any attachment to. I mean no disrespect, every submission is vaild.
Last edited: